How Columbus elects its City Council is on the ballot
This November, Columbus voters will decide two proposed charter amendments that would change how City Council is elected — one placed on the ballot by a citizen petition, one referred by Council itself. Both start from the same arrangement: today’s nine members each represent a district but are elected by the whole city. After talks over a single compromise fell short, Council members and the petition’s organizers now describe the two measures as complementary rather than competing.
The system today
Columbus uses a hybrid system, in place since the 2023 elections. There are nine council members, and each must live in the district they represent — but every voter in the city votes in all nine district races. So members represent a district geographically while answering to the whole city. Both amendments below would change that arrangement in different ways.
The two measures, side by side
According to the Columbus Dispatch, Council placed each amendment on the ballot by an 8–0 vote on Aug. 24; Councilmember Melissa Green was absent but had indicated support for sending both to voters. Dorans said he worked with the City Attorney’s office so that No. 2 would not conflict with No. 1. The final ballot issue numbers are assigned by the Franklin County Board of Elections and may differ from the “No. 1 / No. 2” labels used here.
Can I vote yes on both?
Yes. The two amendments appear as separate ballot questions, and you vote on each one independently — you can support one, both, or neither. Council President Shannon Hardin and several members have said they will encourage voters to approve both, and, the Columbus Dispatch reports, Council drafted its measure with the City Attorney’s office specifically so it would not conflict with the citizen petition. If both pass, how the two fit together is governed by the amendments’ certified text — check the final ballot language and the Franklin County Board of Elections for the authoritative wording.
How we got here
What each side says
Arguments made for the changes
- Supporters of Our City, Our Say say district-only elections give neighborhoods a representative who answers to them directly, and that running in one district costs less than a citywide campaign — lowering the barrier to run.
- Council President Pro Tem Rob Dorans says the four at-large seats in No. 2 preserve a citywide voice on issues that cross district lines, citing transit, housing, and workforce development; per the Columbus Dispatch, he also framed the citywide seats as a way to maintain broad, citywide representation on the council.
- Council President Shannon Hardin and several members say they will encourage voters to support both amendments, and Dorans says No. 2 was drafted with the City Attorney’s office not to conflict with No. 1. (Columbus Dispatch)
Concerns and open questions
- Some labor and Black community leaders have raised concerns about how the changes could affect representation on council. (WOSU, Aug. 2026)
- Adding four at-large seats and a 2028 map redraw makes No. 2 a larger structural change than the petition — voters weigh a straightforward district-only switch against a broader expansion.
- Because both measures can pass, how they would interact is set by the certified amendment text, not yet by any official summary — a reason organizers on both sides point voters to the final ballot language.
Our City, Our Say organizers, including Maitland Neff and Jesse Vogel, have said they do not view Council’s measure as contradictory and regard the effort as good-faith. The points above summarize positions publicly stated by the named parties; they are not endorsements. Columbus Districts is a nonpartisan reference and does not take a position on either measure.
Make your plan to vote
Key 2026 dates
Dates from the Ohio Secretary of State 2026 election calendar; polls are open 6:30 a.m.–7:30 p.m. on Election Day. Confirm details with the Franklin County Board of Elections.
Sources. City Council’s Aug. 24, 2026 votes and the “encourage both” and 8–0 details: Columbus Dispatch, Aug. 24, 2026. The 13-member structure, 2027/2029 at-large phase-in, 2028 commission redraw, and 250→150 district-signature change: WOSU Public Media, Aug. 21, 2026. For the authoritative, certified ballot language and official issue numbers, see the Franklin County Board of Elections and the City Council legislative record.
Last reviewed: September 2, 2026